This Warriors Wednesday question was asked by ♪M!a♪🌸.
*Spoilers for the prequel series.*
Clear Sky had his ups and downs. Sometimes he’s good, sometimes he’s not. I mean, he was one of the reasons the First Battle took place, he rejected his own son, etc. I don’t think I would compare him to Tigerstar. For me, I have to say that Tigerstar wasn’t a bad leader in the terms of the way he led his clan, he was just bad in general.
Clear Sky could have done better, but I think after some time, he became a good leader, he just needed to take his time. It would have been better if he had just been good, but that series needed a overall “bad guy” other than One Eye, who wasn’t in all the books.
Clear Sky provided good conflict for some of the main characters, especially Thunder, Grey Wing and Jagged Peak.
What I didn’t like about him the most was how he treated some cats, like cats who weren’t able to hunt or patrol. For example, when Jagged Peak got wounded, Clear Sky didn’t care that much, he just didn’t want Jagged Peak in his clan because Jagged Peak couldn’t “contribute”.
So, he wasn’t a good leader, but he wasn’t as bad as say, Brokenstar.